Much of northwest Ohio, including Allen County and the counties around it, sits on heavy clay left behind by glacial lake beds — the ground that was drained through the nineteenth century to make the region farmable. It is superb agricultural soil. It is a difficult medium for turf.
Clay particles are extremely fine and pack tightly. That gives the soil real nutrient- and water-holding capacity, but it also means very little pore space for air, poor internal drainage, and a strong tendency to compact under any traffic.
Clay soil is often waterlogged and drought-stressed in the same season, which sounds contradictory and is not. Water that cannot drain drives air out of the root zone, and roots that cannot breathe stay shallow. A shallow-rooted lawn then has access only to the top inch or two of soil, which is the first part to dry.
So the lawn drowns in April and burns in July, and both problems have the same cause.
Clay soils in this region tend to drift acidic over time, and low pH locks up nutrients that are physically present in the soil but unavailable to the plant. That produces the frustrating situation of a lawn being fed properly and still looking hungry.
A soil test settles it, and it is the one piece of information that makes every subsequent decision cheaper. Guessing at lime and nutrients on clay is an expensive habit.
Heavy clay has very little pore space, so water moves through it slowly. Compaction from traffic makes it worse, and low spots concentrate what cannot drain away.
Not replaced, but genuinely improved. Adding organic matter over several seasons, relieving compaction and keeping traffic off it when wet all open the soil up. It is a gradual change rather than a single treatment.
Turf-type tall fescue generally copes best, because it roots deeper than Kentucky bluegrass and handles both wet ground and summer stress better. Most good seed mixes for this region lean on it.
Only a soil test can say. Clay soils in this region often drift acidic, which locks up nutrients already in the soil, but applying lime without testing is as likely to cause a problem as solve one.